NM Incite

Quick Links

The Social Marketer

Aug 24

No Place for Social Media Research in Your Industry? Tell That to Banks.

on August 24, 2012 - 7 Comments

It seems banks have been a bit more reluctant than other industries (like Consumer Packaged Goods or Tech, for example) to integrate social media research into their marketing  efforts. In recent years, banks have been looking to migrate people to lower cost channels: from brick-and-mortar to the phone to the web. It’s slightly ironic that after concerted efforts to push their customers to the web for banking services and product information, all of a sudden banks are paralyzed by today’s ‘social consumer.’ These ‘social consumers’ are talking about their experiences unfiltered online, at times to the detriment of brand health. But I think the tide is slowly shifting and banks are realizing that social media matters to them too, and that ignoring ‘it’ won’t make ‘it’ go away.

In a recent article in American Banker, Sean Sposito looks at the growing trend of banks tapping social media to drive their marketing and customer service efforts. Noting that, “The practice has only recently filtered into the financial services industry, and the largest players in the past several years have just grasped the benefits it could have for business,” Sposito touches on two critical use cases deployed by some of the world’s biggest banks:

  • Product Innovation: BBVA Compass is a pioneer in mining social for product and service enhancements. According to John Wessman, BBVA Compass’ executive vice president and chief marketing officer, BBVA gets “daily insights into consumer reaction to the bank and its competitors. The software we use has sped up BBVA Compass’ reaction to other trends, as well. Over the past two months, the bank has started to consider raising the cash back rewards on its credit cards because one of its larger rivals was receiving positive sentiment on its benefits.” (By the way, I couldn’t help but mention that these insights do happen to come from NM Incite.)
  • Improve Marketing Efficiency by Merging Data Sources: American Express recognized the need to merge traditional market research metrics with social media research and analysis. Christopher J. Frank, Amex’s vice president of its global marketing insights group, stated that “you look at consumer confidence intervals. You look at the overall mood. And we wanted to make sure that we really understood that, and not just from the American Express point of view, but what is on the minds of our customers.” Social media provides an avenue to quickly get a deeper understanding of your consumers – really know their needs, behaviors and wants – so you can confidently develop your marketing strategy.

 

Kudos to banks leading the charge in social media research. In addition to product development and the ability to devise, implement and alter marketing strategies in real-time, we think there is a 3rd opportunity for banks to leverage social. The previously (and sometimes currently) “paralyzed” bank marketer is all too familiar with “I hate Bank XYZ, F*** them, I can’t believe how terrible and impersonal their service is!” popping up on Twitter or the company’s Facebook page. Companies that aren’t geared up for effective social care – a system for companies to regularly provide customer service through social media platforms – will suffer at the hands of the angry consumer and the depth of the consumer’s social network. In fact, McKinsey research shows that one negative post on social media can counteract the effect of five positive posts – so implementing effective social care is critical to the bottom line. Just imagine a world where social media could not only help mitigate negative sentiment, but actually grow and promote positive sentiment  to enhance brand reputation, deepen customer engagement, and even lower costs.

It’s critical for Financial Services marketers to embrace social to win in an industry facing ever-changing regulation, limited product differentiation, and a weakened economic environment. These are three clear opportunities among others I’m sure. I’d love to hear about other examples of how banks can tap social to drive competitive advantage.
 

For more information on how to manage social customer service,
download our white paper: The Social Care Imperative
  • Mick

    Social media is making the relationship manners of businesses transparent. There is great relationship building opportunity in conflict…unfortunately most businesses have had a serious disparity between the resource allocated to acquistion vs retention. Commercial relationships are too easily viewed in cold spread sheet terms, when infact they are human relationships like any other…. i.e. if you only focus on what YOU get then the partner will become despondent/ upset/ angry.

    Whilst there are copious overtures regarding the ‘lifetime value’ of customers and ” keeping a customer is cheaper than acquiring a new one” the fact is very few companies actually put there money where their mouth is. Typically, customer service/ warranty/ after sales budgets are seen as a resource draining, grudge obligation, which needs to be minimised.

    Many corporations have excelled in quantitative analysis of their business with a focus on the core “profitability issue. HR costs and the continual drive to cost reduction have seen a demise in the qualitative aspect of the offering to consumers. As share of voice is owned by the bigger media budget, consumers have typically been unable to do much more than complain to vendors who have increasingly made the management, who can affect change, more remote and difficult to access. progressively we have relegated the customer (you know the ones who spent money with us and provided a profit) from an important partner to a cost bearing problem. a friend in carsales jokes about the “concrete warranty” ..i.e. once you drive off the concrete the warranty is gone….this is in reality how most commerce treats its customers.

    Typically customers have had little means of redress and social media is providing an avenue. They will get better and better at utilising it. A wise operator would take note and a) improve its commitment to customers satisfaction (this will allow leveraging of social media to emphaisie GENUINE positives) and b) ensure it has a means of listening to what is being said as an awareness tool for both itself and competitiors.

    • http://twitter.com/NMIncite_Gadi Gadi Benmark

      Nick, I think I agree. Social media provides a way for companies to reconnect with customers, hear from customers “in their own words”, and let this direct, authentic voice drive decision making throughout the organization. We refer to this as “social care”, and we see it as a catalyst for change. For reference, our recent white paper at http://bit.ly/P4lCaW

      • Dominionebooks.com

        Beauty & Fashion eBooks

  • martyn thomas

    The way to sell in social media is not to sell. The finance industry has laid itself open to criticism over the years through a variety of means, many justified, some not. It can come as no surprise that the very essence of social which is to build long term relationships through compelling and relevant content is a struggle.
    So where to start?
    By listening to and learning from your customers & suppliers to build relationships for the longer term, not acting then measuring with the short term in mind. Most brands are socially inept, finance in particular.
    Negative comments will arise. That’s human nature, but so long as you identify your unique story that gives you permission to publish content then over time you will prevail.
    The real danger in the short term is social cost of inaction (COI). http://www.marketingmag.com.au/blogs/social-media-cost-of-inaction-coi-15994/#.UD_2i5bd58E
    First mover advantage is there to be had so what’s stopping you?
    In Australia we have two banks ‘giving it a go’ but on initial inspection it all appears wafer thin as the new pull-channels are jumped upon with push-mentality…we’ll see.
    Thoughts?

    • http://twitter.com/LCafferty Leslie Cafferty

      I absolutely agree, Martyn, that social is a long-term investment. Without context or benchmarks to track progress against, the insights are largely useless. In addition, earning consumer trust these days is a lot harder than it used to be, so building deep engagement takes commitment. Personally, I think a lot of companies, particularly financial services, are afraid to be aggressive in social. Seeing negative customer sentiment can be paralyzing, particularly when these brands don’t understand the potential value of positive engagement. We will be releasing some interesting data on the value of positive customer engagement in social in the coming weeks, which might help bank marketers overcome this fear.

  • http://www.facebook.com/newshaber.haber Newshaber Haber

    Many corporations have excelled in quantitative analysis of their business with a focus on the core “profitability issue. HR costs and the continual drive to cost reduction have seen a demise in the qualitative aspect of the offering to consumers. As share of voice is owned by the bigger media budget, consumers have typically been unable to do much more than complain to vendors who have increasingly made the management, who can affect change, more remote and difficult to access. progressively we have relegated the customer (you know the ones who spent money with us and provided a profit) from an important partner to a cost bearing problem. a friend in carsales jokes about the “concrete warranty” ..i.e. once you drive off the concrete the warranty is gone….this is in reality how most commerce treats its customers. http://www.newshaberler.com/?p=19197

  • Nell amin

    I think I agree. Social media provides a way for companies to reconnect
    with customers, hear from customers “in their own words”, and let this
    direct, authentic voice drive decision making throughout the
    organization.

    http://www.americanpainexperts.com/